News - Interdyscyplinarne Centrum Etyki (INCET)

Skip banner
INCET logo

BIOUNCERTAINTY - ERC Starting Grant no. 805498

ERC logo

Previous week
Next week

23rd of October 2026 — dr Amber Comer — Life Unworthy of Life: Professional Reorientation and the Object of Protection in Nazi Medicine

Start Time: 12.00
Place: Collegium Broscianum, Kraków
23rd of October 2026  — dr Amber Comer  — Life Unworthy of Life: Professional Reorientation and the Object of Protection in Nazi Medicine

The Jagiellonian University Interdisciplinary Centre for Ethics (INCET) invites you to another open research seminar! Dr. Amber Comer will give a talk on "Life Unworthy of Life: Professional Reorientation and the Object of Protection in Nazi Medicine." The meeting takes place on October 23, 2026, at 12:00 PM in room 25 at 52 Grodzka Street (Collegium Broscianum) and also via MS Teams.

Abstract:

Dominant accounts of physician participation in Nazi medicine emphasize bureaucratic distance, diffusion of responsibility, or authoritarian obedience. This paper argues that the decisive transformation was one of moral realignment rather than moral collapse. Nazi physicians did not abandon medical ethics; they reoriented them by redefining who counted as a patient, and thus whose life fell within the scope of medical protection. By shifting the locus of care from the individual to the Volkskörper, the imagined biological body of the nation, physicians preserved internally coherent ethical reasoning, intact professional identity, and persistent moral language while systematically excluding certain lives from protection entirely.

The paper introduces the concept of the "object of protection" to describe the entity treated as primary within a moral system and argues that Nazi medicine represents a radical narrowing and redirection of that object. Drawing on medical jurisprudence, Rudolf Ramm's ethics manual, and the administrative structure of the T4 program, it identifies three enabling mechanisms: semantic hijacking, in which the language of healing justified elimination; juridical boundary setting, in which law redefined who counted as a patient and thereby removed certain individuals from moral protection; and the elevation of professional moral identity, through which physicians were cast as biological guardians whose obligations to the state superseded duties to individual patients. Within this reframed system, sterilization became prevention, euthanasia became therapy, and selection became triage. This analysis clarifies how preserved moral coherence can accompany profound ethical distortion.

 

Link: https://teams.microsoft.com/meet/3983135154078031?p=J0mfvEdlzHd8rso1IK