News - Interdyscyplinarne Centrum Etyki (INCET)

Skip banner
INCET logo

BIOUNCERTAINTY - ERC Starting Grant no. 805498

ERC logo

December 2024

20241205
Previous week
Next week

5th of December – Daniel Telech – Unwitting yet Praiseworthy Rightdoing: On Negligence’s Positive Analogue

5th of December – Daniel Telech – Unwitting yet Praiseworthy Rightdoing: On Negligence’s Positive Analogue

We have the pleasure to invite you to another research seminar. Daniel Telech is going to give a talk "Unwitting yet Praiseworthy Rightdoing: On Negligence’s Positive Analogue". The seminar will take place on the 5th of December at 5:30 p.m. on Grodzka Street 52, room 25, and via MS Teams.

Abstract

I argue that agents can sometimes be praiseworthy for doing the right thing despite their being unaware of their doing that thing (and not only that it is right). Differently put, I propose that negligence has a positive analogue, which I dub “posigence”. The cases I introduce are ones in which an agent has sufficient reason to act in a way that promotes her own well-being but sets back (or at least, fails to promote) the interests of another, but (unintentionally) omits to do so, manifesting therein exceptionally good quality of will. My argument is conditional in form: those who accept that we can be (directly) blameworthy for negligent wrongdoing should accept that we can similarly be praiseworthy for posigent rightdoing.